Shortlist Stone
Journal

Games Worth Coming Back To

Compare 18 games by what you want from a session, what draws you back and what your hardware can run.

Join the discussion

Start with the second session. A strong shortlist gives you a reason to return, whether that means trying another character build, finding a different route through a mission or seeing what happens in the next chapter.

Decide what you want to do with the time you have. A fighting game can give you a clear goal in a short practice session. An RPG with sprawling side quests suits an evening when you can follow a lead without watching the clock.

The PC Gaming selection takes in several genres, from first-person survival horror to fantasy RPGs and sandbox missions. Bandit Action groups crime, outlaw and undercover stories, with everything from open-world roaming to timed puzzles. The labels describe the two editorial selections, and several Bandit Action games also have PC editions.

Gameplay accounts for 35% of the editorial rubric, presentation 25%, story and world 20%, replay value 10% and accessibility 10%. A focused story can earn its place through strong pacing even if you rarely replay it. Give replay or accessibility more weight in your own decision if either determines whether you’ll keep playing.

Check the exact store listing for your platform, edition contents, controller support and account requirements. For PC, compare your processor, graphics card, memory and free storage with the listed requirements. For consoles, check the supported model and any accessory requirements. The separate GameStop section covers the retailer’s hardware.

Use Find Your Game to narrow the list by the sort of evening you want. Once two or three titles make the cut, read their reviews and compare the practical checks before choosing.

Hardware & merchandise at GameStop

We are an official affiliate partner of GameStop. We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases. GameStop.com is a US store that ships within the continental US.

This section is about GameStop, the video game retailer, not GAMSTOP.

Browse hardware at GameStop

PC Gaming

RPGs, horror, action and stealth: compare the style of play before choosing a platform.

A rain-soaked futuristic city with elevated roads and coloured reflections

Action RPG Elite

Cyberpunk 2077

Editorial score9.2/10

Night City suits a long campaign where the way you build your character can change what you want to try next…

Best for: Character builds and a dense science-fiction setting.

Pros
A dense science-fiction setting and builds that give a repeat run a clear purpose.
Consider
Check the PC requirements for the edition you intend to play.
Read the full review
A windswept medieval village beneath a distant ruined castle

Fantasy RPG Elite

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Editorial score9.1/10

Geralt’s search makes room for detours, so following a side quest can be the point of an evening…

Best for: Long-form fantasy adventures and side quests.

Pros
Exploration, choices and room for long-form fantasy storytelling.
Consider
Detours take time, and expansion contents vary by edition.
Read the full review
A monumental science-fiction fortress above a volcanic canyon

First-person action VIP pick

DOOM Eternal

Editorial score8.8/10

Movement and resource management turn each first-person encounter into a sequence you can refine on a return visit…

Best for: Movement-driven combat and repeatable encounters.

Pros
Repeatable fights with a clear focus on positioning and weapon choice.
Consider
Fast reactions and frequent weapon changes are central demands.
Read the full review
An isolated stone village beside a dark forest at dusk

Survival horror Editor's Elite

Resident Evil 4

Editorial score9.3/10

Leon’s rescue mission uses limited resources to give its third-person action a sustained sense of pressure…

Best for: Focused action and survival decisions.

Pros
Focused progression with meaningful decisions about what to use now and what to save.
Consider
Supply pressure can make it a demanding action game. Check that your listing is for the remake.
Read the full review
A snow-covered village below a distant gothic castle

Survival horror VIP pick

Resident Evil Village

Editorial score8.5/10

The first-person main campaign uses an isolated village and scarce supplies to make exploration tense…

Best for: Atmosphere and tense exploration.

Pros
A strong sense of place and a constant reason to consider your next move.
Consider
Limited supplies suit players who enjoy pressure. Check expansion contents separately.
Read the full review
An abandoned city avenue reclaimed by green plants in warm daylight

Narrative action Editor's Elite

The Last of Us Part I

Editorial score9.3/10

Joel and Ellie’s journey gives the stealth and survival encounters a clear story purpose…

Best for: Character-led storytelling and focused journeys.

Pros
Character-led progression with a defined journey to follow.
Consider
Its focused single-player structure offers a narrower fit for sandbox play. Check hardware requirements and accessibility options by platform.
Read the full review
A timber boat on a cold fjord surrounded by mythic mountain ruins

Action adventure Elite

God of War Ragnarok

Editorial score9.2/10

Travel through the Norse realms gives Kratos and Atreus a mythological setting for a story-driven action adventure…

Best for: Mythological worlds and character-led action.

Pros
A clear fit for readers drawn to character relationships and mythological settings.
Consider
Check hardware requirements and any account conditions on your platform before choosing an edition.
Read the full review
An empty martial-arts courtyard with lanterns and distant mountains

Fighting VIP pick

Mortal Kombat 1

Editorial score8.6/10

The Kameo partner system gives you another choice to consider when practising matchups in short competitive sessions…

Best for: Learning matchups and short competitive sessions.

Pros
A roster to learn, a story campaign and fighter-partner combinations to explore.
Consider
Learning the pairings adds practice time. Check conditions for online modes and extra fighters.
Read the full review
Rooftops and makeshift bridges above an overgrown abandoned city

Survival action Selected

Dying Light 2 Stay Human

Editorial score8.2/10

First-person parkour makes getting across the open world part of the action…

Best for: Traversal and open-world survival.

Pros
Traversal, combat and story choices give you several reasons to explore.
Consider
Check platform support, edition contents and co-op conditions before putting a group together.
Read the full review
An abandoned coastal boulevard with palm trees and bright afternoon light

Action RPG Selected

Dead Island 2

Editorial score8.0/10

Close-range combat anchors this first-person zombie action RPG in Los Angeles, with co-op as an option…

Best for: Close-range action and co-op sessions.

Pros
Suited to players who want melee action and a game to discuss with a regular co-op group.
Consider
Melee is the main draw, and a group should check online requirements and compatibility first.
Read the full review
An elegant empty hotel terrace overlooking a Mediterranean harbour
Editorial score9.2/10

Agent 47’s sandbox locations reward returning with a different route, disguise or plan…

Best for: Planning and replaying sandbox missions.

Pros
Observation and flexible objectives give repeat visits a clear purpose.
Consider
The packages can differ by included location, so compare the contents carefully.
Read the full review
A colourful fictional Caribbean town with hills and weathered buildings

Open-world action Selected

Far Cry 6

Editorial score8.1/10

Yara gives you a fictional island to explore and room to pick your approach to open-world combat…

Best for: Exploring a large world and choosing approaches.

Pros
A large setting for players who like to choose their route and priorities.
Consider
Account conditions, edition contents and co-op requirements need separate checks.
Read the full review

Bandit Action

Crime stories, western journeys and tactical puzzles. These six selections take different approaches to their worlds.

A fictional sunlit west-coast city with freeways and distant hills

Open-world crime Elite

Grand Theft Auto V

Editorial score9.0/10

Los Santos supports a crime story across three protagonists as well as time spent on open-world activities…

Best for: An urban sandbox with several protagonists.

Pros
Several perspectives and an urban sandbox for flexible sessions.
Consider
Legacy and Enhanced editions have different requirements. Verify the exact listing against your setup.
Read the full review
A wooden frontier settlement beside pine forest and a broad mountain valley

Western adventure Editor's Elite

Red Dead Redemption 2

Editorial score9.3/10

Arthur Morgan’s journey with the Van der Linde gang takes a deliberate pace through a changing frontier…

Best for: A slower western journey and world exploration.

Pros
Suited to unhurried exploration and a long western story.
Consider
The pace asks for patience, and storage is worth checking before installation.
Read the full review
A fictional 1930s city street with a period sedan and warm street lamps

Crime adventure Selected

Mafia: Definitive Edition

Editorial score8.3/10

Tommy Angelo’s story gives the fictional 1930s city of Lost Heaven a clear dramatic route through this remake…

Best for: A focused period crime story.

Pros
A focused period crime story with a strong reason to follow the next chapter.
Consider
The story-led structure offers fewer reasons to return if your main interest is free-form sandbox play.
Read the full review
A busy-looking but empty Hong Kong-inspired night street with illuminated market stalls

Open-world crime Selected

Sleeping Dogs

Editorial score8.2/10

Undercover work in Hong Kong links martial-arts combat, driving and a single-player crime story…

Best for: Martial-arts action and an undercover narrative.

Pros
A distinct fit for readers who want hand-to-hand action and an undercover narrative.
Consider
Check compatibility for the older release and confirm the listing is the Definitive Edition.
Read the full review
An industrial Birmingham-inspired canal with brick warehouses and drifting morning mist

Puzzle adventure Selected

Peaky Blinders: Mastermind

Editorial score7.4/10

Several characters’ actions share a timeline, so puzzle progress depends on getting their moves to line up…

Best for: Planning and synchronised character puzzles.

Pros
A good match for players who enjoy planning sequences and adjusting their timing.
Consider
Its appeal rests on synchronised puzzles. Check regional availability for this previously released game.
Read the full review
Victorian London rooftops above a foggy street and a railway station

Historical action Selected

Assassin's Creed Syndicate

Editorial score8.2/10

Jacob and Evie Frye’s story takes stealth, traversal and gang conflict through Victorian London…

Best for: Historical city exploration and stealth.

Pros
A historical city to explore with stealth as a reason to observe how spaces fit together.
Consider
Confirm platform compatibility and account conditions for this older release.
Read the full review

How we choose and score games

Scores are editorial assessments based on the cited product information and the weighted rubric below. Use them alongside genre, edition details and the kind of session you want. A higher score can still be a poor fit for your preferences.

  • Gameplay (35%)
  • Presentation (25%)
  • Story / world (20%)
  • Replay value (10%)
  • Accessibility (10%)

Each criterion is assessed on a ten-point scale. The weighted result is rounded to one decimal place. Our selection covers paid games for an adult readership; check each product’s own age classification.

Gaming sites comparison

Compare games and their official product destinations. Scores refer to the game; check the linked listing for edition details, requirements and regional availability.

GameEditorial scoreProsConsiderWhere to play
Cyberpunk 2077Editorial score9.2/10A dense science-fiction setting and builds that give a repeat run a clear purpose.Check the PC requirements for the edition you intend to play.Check official listing
The Witcher 3: Wild HuntEditorial score9.1/10Exploration, choices and room for long-form fantasy storytelling.Detours take time, and expansion contents vary by edition.Check official listing
DOOM EternalEditorial score8.8/10Repeatable fights with a clear focus on positioning and weapon choice.Fast reactions and frequent weapon changes are central demands.Check official listing
Resident Evil 4Editorial score9.3/10Focused progression with meaningful decisions about what to use now and what to save.Supply pressure can make it a demanding action game. Check that your listing is for the remake.Check official listing
Resident Evil VillageEditorial score8.5/10A strong sense of place and a constant reason to consider your next move.Limited supplies suit players who enjoy pressure. Check expansion contents separately.Check official listing
The Last of Us Part IEditorial score9.3/10Character-led progression with a defined journey to follow.Its focused single-player structure offers a narrower fit for sandbox play. Check hardware requirements and accessibility options by platform.Check official listing
God of War RagnarokEditorial score9.2/10A clear fit for readers drawn to character relationships and mythological settings.Check hardware requirements and any account conditions on your platform before choosing an edition.Check official listing
Mortal Kombat 1Editorial score8.6/10A roster to learn, a story campaign and fighter-partner combinations to explore.Learning the pairings adds practice time. Check conditions for online modes and extra fighters.Check official listing
Dying Light 2 Stay HumanEditorial score8.2/10Traversal, combat and story choices give you several reasons to explore.Check platform support, edition contents and co-op conditions before putting a group together.Check official listing
Dead Island 2Editorial score8.0/10Suited to players who want melee action and a game to discuss with a regular co-op group.Melee is the main draw, and a group should check online requirements and compatibility first.Check official listing
HITMAN World of AssassinationEditorial score9.2/10Observation and flexible objectives give repeat visits a clear purpose.The packages can differ by included location, so compare the contents carefully.Check official listing
Far Cry 6Editorial score8.1/10A large setting for players who like to choose their route and priorities.Account conditions, edition contents and co-op requirements need separate checks.Check official listing
Grand Theft Auto VEditorial score9.0/10Several perspectives and an urban sandbox for flexible sessions.Legacy and Enhanced editions have different requirements. Verify the exact listing against your setup.Check official listing
Red Dead Redemption 2Editorial score9.3/10Suited to unhurried exploration and a long western story.The pace asks for patience, and storage is worth checking before installation.Check official listing
Mafia: Definitive EditionEditorial score8.3/10A focused period crime story with a strong reason to follow the next chapter.The story-led structure offers fewer reasons to return if your main interest is free-form sandbox play.Check official listing
Sleeping DogsEditorial score8.2/10A distinct fit for readers who want hand-to-hand action and an undercover narrative.Check compatibility for the older release and confirm the listing is the Definitive Edition.Check official listing
Peaky Blinders: MastermindEditorial score7.4/10A good match for players who enjoy planning sequences and adjusting their timing.Its appeal rests on synchronised puzzles. Check regional availability for this previously released game.Check official listing
Assassin's Creed SyndicateEditorial score8.2/10A historical city to explore with stealth as a reason to observe how spaces fit together.Confirm platform compatibility and account conditions for this older release.Check official listing

Hardware platforms comparison

PlatformWhere to PlayWhere to Buy
PCCheck the game’s PC listingBrowse hardware at GameStop
PlayStationCheck the PlayStation StoreBrowse hardware at GameStop
XboxCheck the Xbox storeBrowse hardware at GameStop
Nintendo SwitchCheck Nintendo eShopBrowse hardware at GameStop
CloudCheck Xbox Cloud GamingDigital service

Comments